The Best Sandwich Shop

Meh…. I was expecting a fantastic sandwich based on their name and was disappointed. The chicken tasted off and lacked any interesting flavor. The vibe of the place was lacking as well. Service was just average. I've had a way better sandwich for $20. I will try and find a homeless person to give this untouched half of a sandwich, too.

OMG!!! I got the hatch chile burger and it was AMAZING! Absolutely top 5 burgers... now I forgot to grab ketchup... that would have made it even better. But it wasn't heavy in my stomach... it was super flavorful and delicious.

Man, these sandwiches were about as one note as the day is long. They will put like a sweet chili relish on a sandwich and it will be the only thing you can taste. The meat is bland and the bread just kinda tastes like white bread from any fast food sandwich shop. Dave's Cosmic subs and Fred's are both better choices.

Good portions and tasty food. Pricey beers compared to other places we went in Atlanta.

Chocolate chip cookie was a little hard but tasty. Couldn’t break off without using a knife.

It started with no one acknowledging me standing at the counter waiting to order. I had to go find someone. Then they made sure I knew that the dining room was closed and I could not eat there. Then I ordered a turkey sandwich and was told they are out of turkey. It’s a sandwich shop that claims to be the “Best Sandwich Shop”. Not so much. Quite possibly the worst. They made it very clear that making me a sandwich was not on their to-do list for today. I won’t go back.

This day, I wanted a sandwich so bad, so I stopped by this establishment. I was greeted when I walked through the door. There was only 1 person dining in. I stood looking at the menu for a while, and the guy at the register and another guy standing next to him just sat there waiting. I guess I was expecting a little more customer service. Have you been here before? What do you have a taste for? Nope, none of that! I ordered the Sunset Blvd, and it left more to be desired. It had no flavor, it was just Blah, very bland! The best thing it had going was the bacon! The sesame seed roll should be an option because WHY! The $3 pickle was TERRIBLE, extremely sweet and vinegary (that might not be a word but you get the point). It was 12:30 in the afternoon and claimed they just ran out of potato chips! $17 lunch that I regretted. I ate half the sandwich and took everything else home for my husband to try. We mutually agreed on the bland sandwich and the disgusting pickle. Sorry I won't be back!

This place is my top pick for best “Northeast Sub Shop” in Atlanta. Their unofficial chicken parm is packed full of chicken, sauce, and cheese and paired with the sesame seed roll is chef’s kiss. The Best Sandwich Shop also does “Philly Style” subs really well too, but be wary that once they sell out of meats for them during the day, they’re 86’d until the next day.