Witch Way Gifts

Not only is it the best witch themed gift shop in Salem it's one of the best gifts shops anywhere period. They have anything and positively everything witch related that you could possibly ask for. The owner and staff we spoke with were very helpful, knowledgeable, and super friendly. You should stop in here and check it out for sure.

Amazing is all I can say ! I absolutely recommend this store if ever given the chance to visit ! I came from Chicago and I definitely will come back just for this store ! Couldn’t ask for better personnel working behind the counter

Really cool place to get your Salem merch. Reasonably priced (cheaper than the place that changed their name). Staff is very friendly. Will definitely return.

Got here extremely quick and exceeded all expectations thank you

I would leave 0 stars if I could. The customer service is awful. I purchased a cheap $5 broomstick witch pen and while using the register pen to sign the receipt, the female employee grabbed the pen from my hand as if I was stealing their product by saying, “I’ll take that.” I spoke to the manage/owner regarding the incident because I found it appalling for a customer to be treated so rudely. The manager stated, “I’m going to excuse her behavior due to it being a stressful time of year.” I’m not sure what is stressful about selling magnets and shot glasses, but if that’s stressful, then it’s best their hidden in a back alley and not on the main tourist strip.

I won’t say my Trip to Salem was horrible , the history was interesting to learn about , the scenery was beautiful and like others I have a fascination with Witches. But if you go to one Witch store you’ve seen them all. One thing I can say is this town is one of the most expensive places I have ever visited and I have traveled a lot. 99.9% of the Witch shops have the most over priced items it was offensively ridiculous . This store was the first I had visited and the only one I have purchased from. Their prices are super affordable and the quality of there items sold was on point . The older gentleman I think might be the owner was very friendly . I bought a decorative box from them and after giving them the display box they of course handed me one new in a packaged box. I took it back and saw some slight differences and I called asking if I could possibly get an exchange . Without question they gave me the one I wanted which was the display and they even had a bin with free items that had been defective or I’m assuming returned. Shockingly it was actually nice quality free items so it was nice to see a store so openly giving to others. This coming from a town that charges for absolutely everything I’m shocked they didn’t change for the air we were breathing. So if you’re looking for authentic and fairly priced items this is the store to go to. (Ps not throwing hate towards Salem I loved it I just hated how expensive it was to do anything at all.)

Great shop for finding anything witchy or Salem related. Spent an hour in there and still did not get to check out everything in the store.