Mayer Bros Cider Mill

Everything is always good. Very small inside. Love when the guys are outside with the kettle corn

I'm sad to say after a 1/2 a dozen years coming here.
With another 3 working here. I come to find my favorite holiday person was letgo. Colleen always made sure the store was clean, prepped, coffee was hot, and everyone in the store was taken care of with a smile. It's saddens me to know she's gone from the company and as I walked through the store today with coffee all over the counters, the shelves a mess,
I could feel her absence.

I miss you Colleen, Mayer brothers will never be the same without you

Local institution. Fantastic! Apple cider, donuts baked fresh made with the apple cider and without in multiple varieties. Amazing pies and other desserts. Huge selection of locally made and canned sauces, condiments and preserved products. Fudge, candy, cheese curd from New York state and other goodies along with seasonal decor. They serve cider slushies and hot apple cider during certain times of the year.

Can get *extremely busy* on the weekends and weekday nights closer to Halloween. Prepare to wait in line outside if you are going during those times. Extra parking across the street and down the road a bit past the cemetery. Don't recommend parking right in front as it can be extremely difficult to get out with the busy road.

The donuts were delicious as always, they never disappoint there. The customer service (at the donut counter at least) is never great but tonight it was horrible. To be fair we did walk in about 5 minutes before closing however in my defense when I Googled the hours when I pulled in the parking lot it was still showing 8pm. So myself and my daughter went in to grab 4 donuts and literally stood there with an employee ignoring us 3inches from our faces like she thought we were going to leave if she kept ignoring us. Eventually she saw we were not leaving and unfortunately helped us, she didn’t say a word, threw our donuts in the bag then just shoved the bag at us. I understand they were closing and she was annoyed but none of that was necessary, I didn’t know they were closing and they were technically still open…if she would have immediately helped us we would have been out of her face in less than 10 seconds. I am beyond tired of going places to spend my money and dealing with bad attitudes.

Nice shop! Maple donut, granulated sugar donut, and apple "fruit stick" were all good. I chuckled that the last item wasnt called a strudle. The hot cider was tasty, though only slightly warmer than room temp.

The surrounding shop has lots of good gift giving items and "throw back" candy.

*I liked the idea of halloween trick or treat tokens for a frozen cider (i just dont live in the state to use them).

Had a great time. So many memories of coming here as a kid. Amazing to share this with my daughter!!

THE place for apple cider and all things related. So delicious. I would have given it 4.5 stars if I had that option. Didn't give a 5 because the wait to go in has way out the door. Inside there was only one cashier but 6 cash registers. If you don't mind the wait, and can find a parking place, 5+.