Top Pie shops in New York, United States

All these years after living in the New York City, I’ve been coming across a lot about this bakery and its famous banana pudding. Thus, right after Christmas I decided to stop by this bakery after my work to take out the pudding.

It was quite a cute shop at the Bleeker Street in West village. There was a line, but it was fast moving. The guys behind the counter were quick and helpful. I picked up a small banana pudding container and since it was holiday season they’ve their holiday special Red Velvet cheesecake which was looking utterly delicious.

Now, writing about the taste, like any other folk I loved the pudding - freshly made, rich in flavor, and mouthwatering. Next time I’m definitely going to get a big container.

Being a red velvet enthusiast, the cheesecake was luscious and yummy! A must try during the holiday season.

Kudos to the team.

Love and a Happy new year,
Amey! ❤️

My wife liked the location by Central Park over “original location.” I think it was due to the other locations sat longer in the fridge compared to the fresh one licked up here. I still loved the lemonade!!

My friend tried the red velvet cupcake and loved it! I can’t have anything here because I avoid products with egg. I wish they had more plant-based options!
Their legendary banana pudding was sold out when we visited, so I’d suggest getting there earlier in the evening if you’d like to try it. Apart from the food, this location is unique because it’s the original/first Magnolia Bakery location. The staff were polite and efficient, and the store itself is a quaint, visual treat!

I was so excited to try Magnolia Bakery's famous "banana pudding". It was good but did not live up to the hype. The cupcake was nothing special than the regular grocery market's cupcake. Original banana pudding was better than red velvet.

We could not leave New York without having a taste of its iconic banana pudding. The banana pudding was great and not too sweet which aids in binge eating the entire large cup. But my favourite was the blueberry cheesecake which was tastier than their banana pudding for me. I loved their blueberry cheesecake so much that I couldn’t even wait to click a picture before devouring it.

NYC MUST TRY. I personally don’t even eat bananas HOWEVER this banana pudding is amazing. Everyone has their own opinions but I think if you have not tried Magnolia’s Banana Pudding… YOU SHOULD! It’s a perfect snack while roaming around NYC. There are many convenient locations, grab a spoon and enjoy!!

Only tried the banana pudding and the apple crisp pudding. I'm not super into bananas but the banana pudding was still good. The apple crisp stuff is incredible though, if they aren't sold out. The other problem is that what you get is a little inconsistent. Sometimes it's heavier on pudding, other times on the vanilla wafers. I haven't had one heavy on apples yet, but I've had one that had only a single piece of apple. That said it's still good, just not as good. Definitely recommend taking the risk as it's good no matter what.

Five star for Banana pudding. The texture and flavor both are amazing withou too sweet.
Brownie fudge one is ok. Blueberry pie is too sweet for me though.
The shop is not so much crowded when I visited in the late afternoon.