Top American restaurants in Summit, United States

Everything was terrific ! We got Ceasar salad with chicken, truffled mushroom flatbread, roasted corn, Brussels sprouts, tso’s cauliflower, it’s not in the picture but we also ordered truffled fries and baked parker house rolls which was so delicious. Thomas was our server he was so nice and friendly . Def look for Richard the manager. He is the best. This was our first time we will definitely be back. I highly recommend you this restaurant.

We totally enjoyed Huntley Tavern! A spur of the moment stop that we will visit again. Great hospitality and service. We thoroughly enjoyed our lunch. Great selection of wine, too🥂 I ordered the Vermont burger, medium rare that was cooked to perfection. My grandson had the same medium, together with homemade lemonade. My son ordered the Warm Smoked Turkey & Brie Sandwich, which he loved! A great lunch experience!!

Sorry, no pictures, we were too hungry, ate everything right the way :)
First of all, the hostesses were very nice and helpful. Our server Thomas was very professional and attentive. All the staff was very well groomed, polite, and professional.
The food was delicious, and drinks were well designed. Very classy and somewhat cozy atmosphere.
Will definitely be back.
Highly recommend!

Went there for my engagement and the staff was so incredibly friendly! Food/drinks came out in a timely manner. The food was amazing, as were the drinks! For dessert they brought out an extra offering for our celebration with a candle! It was such a special night here. Thank you to all the staff!!

We have been wanting to try out Huntley Tavern for a while, but it has always been full with a long wait time when we go for a walk in, so we made a reservation last night. Seeing how popular the place is and reading the menu ahead of time, we were really looking forward to it, unfortunately it was a let down. Nothing was bad, the steak was cooked well, the scallops were tender if a little gritty, but nothing was great. It was all pretty bland and lacking flavor. Definitely expected to be wowed by the food considering the price.

Drinks were good.
Staff was very friendly.

For the price and quality, I would say you're better off going somewhere else in the area.

I was impressed with this restaurant, we enjoyed the food as well as the ambiance and service. I came for a business lunch. Ate inside the porch area that was enclosed. I thought the service was very good in terms of attentiveness. The food we got was flat bread pizza for appetizer, pepperoni with hot honey was delicious. The burger tasted great cooked perfectly when I ordered a medium, presentation was nice as I ordered a salad instead of French fries. Most importantly they had Aqua Pana for water. I did think the prices were a bit inflated and expensive however their service made up for it.

We had three entrées:
Scallops (5 stars),
Short ribs, (5),
Filet Mignon (only 4 stars) because it needed seasoning. It needed a more v salted crust.
The side dish of rot kohl, red cabbage, was also tasty, but could have been so much better had they seasoned more.

Next time I go, and we will go again, I'll try the scallops.

Starters we had the rolls, expensive, but good.
Creamy Burrata was outstanding.

Desserts were a good a they get.
We had the sunday, premium ice cream with stuff, excellent.
The chocolate cream pie was great. Chocolate filling was perfect, dark chocolate, not too sweet. Cream perfect too, not too sweet. Crust was a bit too stuff, not flaky like it could have been better. But again, chocolate and cream were perfect, so I'd certainly get it again.

Service was great. Ambiance was perfect.

Great place for special date or family or even flying solo at the bar.

Love Huntley Taverne. Used to come here for business dinners prior to the pandemic, and forgot about the wonderful the food, service and dining room. The tuna tartare appetizer was fresh, tho a tad salty. Chicken Cobb salad was filling and more than enough for brunch.