Top Sushi restaurants in Garden City, United States

They're 3 sushi restaurant on this street
Kaji sushi is my favourite restaurant, friendly staff, always serve great food, highly recommend

Service is utterly HORRIBLE! Walked we see a lady behind the bar eating on the floor! We ignored it because there was no one in the restaurant!

Sometime past so only my husband and I were in this restaurant. We placed our orders had our appetizers. While we ate our apps about 15 people come in. We waited an entire hour for our entrees! While other people received their entrees before us!!

We waited another half hour for to go boxes after a customer next to us got everything boxed any ready to go!

Terrible filet served and they just sautéed it in the pan after we cut it up in our plates smh! Terrible

Have had great experiences at the old location. Since the move, I have only been able to dine one time. Made a reservation and was told there was going to be a 45 minute wait minimum. Another time, put my name on the wait list and was told 30 minutes and got a call 1 hour and 30 minutes later. The takeout is a mess as well. Would love to see management step up and solve the reservation and walk in situation. The poor hostess was clearly overwhelmed and seemed to have no guidance from managers.

Ordered the sashimi appetizer and Alaska roll for takeout. Roll was salty but fine, sashimi however was really bad, wound up not eating it. Weird chewy texture, smell off one of the fish, and small sloppy cuts. I don't like leaving bad reviews but can't believe they served it in that condition.

What a wonderful experience we had. I booked a holiday party for some customers and everything was wonderful. The food was outstanding, the atmosphere was wonderful with huge screen TVs playing mixed martial arts it was a lot of fun! The service was impeccable - they literally cater to your every need. My customers were delighted, and my expectations were far exceeded! whether you're going with a large group, with a few others, or just by yourself to grab some sushi, you won't be disappointed! I will be coming back and will, of course, entertain customers there again. What a great experience. Thank you, Kinha Sushi owners, management, and staff!

This was a very unique sushi experience with lots to enjoy. I usually just get sashimi when I go to sushi places but the sushi rolls they offer were just too good to pass up. Restaurant decor modern beautiful. great design!!! Their stuff very friendly. Highly recommend!!!

I really like the food there. My friend recommended me to check it out and I am glad that I did.. We ordered different type of sushi and lobster miso soups. The soup very delicious !! My friends really love it too. We will come back. Highly recommended!

We arrived at 9:30 on a Monday night, just before the 10 pm closing time, seeking a quick bite. Despite finishing by 10:06 pm, the experience was disappointing. Our order included two rainbow rolls and a specialty roll with mango, and unfortunately, the sushi fell below the standards of even gas station or grocery store sushi. This stands as the worst sushi experience I've had on Long Island – the rolls were poorly made, dry, and tasted horrible. The subpar quality, especially given the price, has led me to decide i will never come back here again. I strongly advise against choosing this place for sushi; opting for grocery store sushi would likely yield a better experience. This establishment doesn't deserve your business.

We visited here for the first time since moving into town 2 years ago. The food was decent but seemed overpriced. There are other options like Taku (even though it is not known as a sushi restaurant) that has better food and is cheaper. Also, this place charges a "non-cash fee" which is unfortunate.

The best sushi and sashimi on long island!!
Excellent service and great atmosphere!!

I got a lunch combo with 3 sushi rolls and the sushi was good and definitely fresh! Reasonably priced as well ($15) for three rolls, a salad and soup. And the soup was great too.

First time here . We ordered sushi and ramen. We arrived at lunch time , they only offered dinner menu. I had to ask for the lunch menu… The food was decent but the service wasn’t welcoming. I will not return

It's still amazing! It's a destination stop every time we are in Long Island!

I simply cannot rate Sushi Ya Garden City highly enough. We live in Delaware and it is our favorite sushi place because nothing in Delaware measures up. Kelly and Eric the owners are fantastic, and everything they make is devine. The quality and selection of sushi and sashimi is outstanding. The little touches like fresh wasabi (as opposed to the usual little green ball) are excellent. The pineapple fried rice served in a half pineapple shell are to die for. Hibachi is available. Simply in ambiance, service, and quality there is simply no place that is better. Give yourself a treat and spend some time here.

Good but not great. Pretty good sushi , plenty to choose from. The spring rolls are a bit too oily.

I came here for dinner. I loved the ambiance and food. Great service! I highly recommend it.

The food is absolutely amazing, customer service is great. My husband and I had our first date here 8 years ago. Since then, Kinha has become our favorite Japanese Restaurant.

I would not have expected the quality of sushi that I received from a restaurant with such a high general rating. Especially because there are some very good local sushi options, so it's always surprising when restaurants let such a bad order through. Maybe I caught them on a bad day, and don't know how interested I'll be in giving this place another shot just given local competition, but did want to post this review so that others can be aware.

Included in our order was a sashimi set and 3 separate rolls. There was huge variance in color between individual pieces in the rolls, and in the sashimi. This in itself can be ok and not always a sign of freshness, but unfortunately the taste proved the deciding factor as certain pieces were definitely fishy/rancid. Tuna had black/grey splotches, which I have never seen before. As stated, while visual cues aren't a definitive sign of freshness, they are a sign to be on your guard. I was lucky in that the taste immediately came through as not right, and was further confirmed through other slices of fish.

Edit: Added pictures of the tuna. The camera does not capture the grey splotches as well as I hope, but you can see more clear grey coloring along the inner edge.

Highly recommend Kinha as your new go to sushi spot. Everything is absolutely delicious and I would say their sushi is among the freshest you can get on the Island! A beautiful interior & the attentive staff created an excellent dining experience all around!

We come to the new kinha sushi last week with family and it was just great. Sushi and sashimi are fresh and amazing. The dinning room is nice and clean. Service was outstanding.

Amazing sushi!!! The owners were super friendly and the sashimi just amazing….love it

Nice atmosphere, good service, food came timely and as expected. Just tried basic options this time but I would like to go back and try some special rolls.

Appetizers
Rock shrimp, it was fine
miso soup, it was fine
avocado salad - it was fine for avo on iceberg lettuce

Entrees
Salmon with cucumber roll- ok
tuna roll- ok
sashimi deluxe- cool variety of different fish to try

This was a very nice place for Japanese food. I got the chicken hibachi (comes with a side of soup & salad), california roll and shrimp tempura roll. Side note: everyone at the table got the same thing except for the kids. It was fairly empty when I visited, which was a Sunday evening. I was surprised to see it no too full since it was dinner time. Overall the staff was nice, place was spacious, and the food was good

I've been here a couple of times and I must say there Signature Sushi, Udon, Soba are on point. Appetizers are also really good like the Rock Shrimp Tempura, Kobe Beef and the Jaiozi.

The inside is nice and with a subtly dark background, so if you like a subtle dark space you'll like it. The have 3-4 High tables on the front side of the restaurant, the walls of the restaurant have booth-like seating on both sides and standard 2x3 tables with chairs towards the middle of the restaurant.a small middle sector with 5 tables and only chair seating.

I personally like the 3 tables of Japanese Seating with cushions 2 tables for four people and 1 for two people. It's like the traditional Japanese seating but it's built in seats make it so that you can sit normally at standard seat height. Pretty eye catching if I'm honest and makes you wanna sit there w/some Sushi/Udon and Sake. IMO it's just has a good vibe to it and it's pretty unique.

The sake is really good. I prefer cold sake with Fuji Apple. The Lychee is an adquired taste but not bad at all. They got a bar in the back so you can get your standard shot, Teq's, Vodka's, Beers and etc. Margarita's and Specialty drinks are also available.

I won't give it 5 stars due to the Ramen and they served 1 of my children last. I don't think it was on purpose due to the size of my group, but IMO ALL the children should be served before the adults in any Restaurant's Serving Standards.
Besides that the staff are friendly and attended us well. They come to the table a good amount of time in between. They clear the tables and don't rush you you to order. All in all pretty good.

The Ramen was standard nothing too crazy. If they improve on the Ramen Bowls they could definitely see more customers. I know people that go far for Ramen so if they have some 🔥 Ramen nearby even better for Customers and BUSINESS. More flavor on the meat of choice and the broth a customer orders and they could see a sea of people come in especially WINTER.

A reminder they are a Sushi Specialty Restaurant, so the Ramen being standard isn't a surprise. Fo'Sho they got the Rolls & Udon/Soba on the dot.

I have my opinion on the Ramen heavily due to my taste and likes and I would like to see it improved. Hell might see me every week...

The Bento boxes are assorted and you can get Hibachi or Teriyaki Boxes/Entrees. The got a bit of everything as you would expect and you can try different combo's for something with more your taste. I prefer the UDON/SOBA or the Drunken Rice Noodles.

They finesse the flavor and it's the right amount or salt. Not overbearing/rubbery at all and goes well with a Fuji Apple Sake IMO.

Mochi was nice and decorated pretty. They have a good amount of flavors, even green tea. Tempura Cheesecake was Delicious, HOT and went down smoothly after eating it. It was like a crunchy creamy churro with a subtle sweet and obvious cheesecake flavor. It all melted really well. Some Hot Tea and Cheesecake in the Winter; that's some nice stuff. They even got Tartufo which is nice if you want something chocolaty, but smooth and cold

All in all if you can try the UDON, SOBA AND TEMPURA CHEESECAKE. Obviously the Sushi and Rolls as well but that goes without saying. Oh, and the Sake; 18+.

Anything I stated that may have seemed negative; was in light of hoping that it can be tweaked. Presentation on any of the dishes is special and their plating is eye-catching and is something one learns to appreciate, especially on the Sushi.

It's reasonably priced as well and the sushi pricing especially. Apps are worth especially the ones mentioned above IMO.

Entree's/Dishes, Non-AL Drinks, Dessert should cost ya anywhere from all together from 25 to 40.

The same estimate goes for the Rolls assuming you get two of them. Get only one roll and you drop to around 20-30.

With AL Drinks add 15 to 40 bucks especially the specialty drinks or bottles for non brand in-house drinks. Without dessert take away 8-12 bucks from the cost add-up.

That's all she wrote.....

Our family loves this restaurant and it seems we end up visiting on a weekly basis! We eat sushi often, also making it at home, and think the quality here is great. The food is consistently fresh and prepared with care. Min is wonderful as well!