Local Guides World

Ryan Stanley

1 reviews on 1 places
Horse Thieves Tavern
2024 May 05
Second visit where we were disappointed. Clam chowder- watery and tasted like nothing. Fish & chips- it was like breaded scraps of fish (like 3-4 tiny pieces on the edge of the plate of fries) and the slaw flavor was straight acidic/tangy nothing else- like out of balance in a way that does not taste good. Shepherd’s pie- barely anything there below the potatoes, the meat and veggies that were there tasted like absolutely nothing. It was very odd overall. Vibe of the place is great so we were excited- it was just a very odd thing to have every last thing on your table taste like literally nothing (except the fries). This could’ve been a bad night for them so I’m not intending to hit them too hard in rating but given it’s the second time and similar experiences, folks should know. I’d come here for a drink but nothing other than that going forward.