Sanzari's New Bridge Inn

I came to this restaurant on a Thursday afternoon after looking at the reviews online. I had high hopes as the reviews were good however, my experience did not live up to those expectations.

I sat in the bar area and started with a mocktail, here lies the first problem. My request for a mocktail, since I'm pregnant, turned into confusion and an across the room conversation with a woman who I assumed to be a bar manager or another employee off duty. I typically ask a waiter if they can make a mocktail and if they have a creative bartender. I am completely open to anything the bartender would make within a specific flavor profile. I ended up getting sparkling water mixed with pineapple juice. Completely fine, but just not what I expected based off the reviews.

I ended up eating the French onion soup which came out fast and was good for what it was.

Finally, I had asked my waiter what his favorite item was out of the specials on the menu and he randomly pointed to one, the fettuccine and shrimp, and said "that would be interesting." Again, this is not what I expect when I read the review about service. I would have been more than happy to have a $50+ tab however, I ended up leaving shortly after finishing the soup because I didn't feel that my experience would have improved.

I ate at the bar and it was a wonderful experience! Tony Ann the bartender was perfect at making drinks and taking our order! Her bright smile and kind nature was noticed by all. We loved the atmosphere and the food was terrific. I had the shrimp scampi and thoroughly enjoyed it. The bread was also perfect as well. I will definitely be back!

When you want a bit of upscale atmosphere and food with an Italian flair, Sanzari’s is a great choice. The dress code is casual/whatever but the dining area makes for a classy atmosphere. The food is delicious and the portions are very satisfying. The wait staff folks are friendly and attentive. The prices are on the higher side but worth it. Parking is usually valet.

Needed to get off the grid. Tucked away in New Milford, NJ. Soft shell crabs and took home what I really went there for char grilled cheese burger. Amazing, every morsel was a true delight. Oh wait I had dessert in between. A must have and an escape with new found friends.

Other than the confusion about where the parking lot entrance was, this eatery has a homey feel about it. I recently experienced being a guest at a bridal shower in the upstairs room and it was cozy. The food was good (nothing spectacular though, although I give the penne with vodka sauce a "two thumbs up".) and the service was good too. I didn't understand two things: why bread plates weren't put on the tables [we had to make due with our saucers from our coffee cups] and the coffee was served way past the serving of the plates of cookies. Correct me if I'm wrong, but we couldn't understand why pitchers of soda weren't provided either. Would I return for an evening meal? Probably.

Attended a fundraiser Gala for a local school and we were in the outdoor tent in mid-March. We were not cold at all. They had valet for our guests. Could have benefited from a coat check, but everything else was amazing. Sam & his staff were very professional. We went a little over our 11 pm exit time but did not feel like we were getting kicked out. I would personally use this venue in the future.

We received a gift card to dine here. We've never been here before. When we walked in we were greeted warmly and promptly seated in a beautifully decorated room with a warm homey feel. The servers were so friendly, attentive, but not intrusive, and very helpful, even supplied a stand to hold purses off the floor.
The food was perfectly prepared. Started with complimentary warm loaves of bread served with Olive Oil and sundried tomatoes - so good! From appetizers to dessert, each bite, each entrée was thoroughly enjoyed! We started with Coconut Shrimp, Shrimp Cocktail and stuffed mushrooms. The shrimp were of an impressive size, not too much but oh so good! The stuffed mushrooms portion of 4 good-sized mushrooms caps generously stuffed to delight! The prime rib was made perfectly and served with horseradish, potatoes, a delicious bread muffin and veggies. The homemade lasagna did not disappoint with its generous portion and topped with freshly shredded cheese, so good! The filet mignon was exquisite. So tender and bursting with flavor! The mashed red potatoes were creamy and whipped to perfection. Roasted veggies on the side were savory as well. The portions, overall, were more than we could eat, so we happily requested our leftovers to be packed to brought home. We ended the evening the Chocolate Mousse served with fresh whipped cream, so good! The prices are a little steep for us, but wow! Well worth it! We look forward to (hopefully getting another gift certificate and) returning! If you're the type who doesn't mind paying a little more than usual for an outstanding meal, amazing service and a beautiful atmosphere, then I highly recommend Sanzari's!