Tottenville Bagels Inc

Walked in to an empty store and ordered a bagel and cheese on a toasted scooped plain bagel. Received a bagel non toasted with non melted cheese and egg shells in the egg. What has happened to this place over the years? So disappointing.

I've ordered from this place multiple times and the order is always incorrect. It's a shame because the food is good however I'm tired of paying for incorrect orders and will no longer order from here. I would suggest check your order before leaving the store.

Dont order delivery they send burnt food

Today I wanted to order coffee. I was standing in line, when it was my turn, he said that he wanted to serve the other person first. He said if you don't like it, you can leave the store. And I said ok and left the store. I do not recommend this place, disgusting service.

This places I think they changed ownership and now it’s a dumb
I ask if they have a gluten-free bagel And Mr BANGLADESH start making funny remarks! Nasty staff and I will never go back to this store .

Tottenville Bagels is my favorite deli on Staten Island due to it being one of the only places I can get a few products I really like such as Tiramisù in a glass, Orange strawberry banana juice and the spiciest buffalo wings on Staten island. As an in-joke I used to call it Hot BS Bagels because of the way most of the sign's letters weren't lit up. The place is fairly small on the inside but very strategically placed I would say, being right on the corner of Page and Amboy road. Some other things I got were Nutella breadsticks and other types of juices.

In the end, Tottenville Bagels is the only deli I go directly out of my way to go to since they have some amazing exclusive products that I enjoy so much that I would gladly make the trek to Tottenville Bagels to stock up on.

I have been a patron of this store for over 20 years. To be more precise, use to go here all the time about 10 years ago. My office changed locations so went less frequently over the years. Just recently I am doing some work in the area and have been going to them daily again. I am not sure of anyones names but literally every single person I deal with is helpful, acts courteous, and is always pleasant to me. While there, many customers came in, and the employees greeted them with their first name, "Good morning," and before the customer could even speak they knew the order and just confirmed. I see this every time I go here. I am in this store in the morning hours never the afternoon or evenings. I do order different things from a breakfast platter to a plain bagel with cream cheese. Not a coffee drinker so cant comment on that. The food has always been very good. I highly recommend them.