Mellow Mushroom College Park

Walked in and sat at the bar. Bartender was Tony and we were ignored for the entire time we sat at the bar. A young man from the kitchen had to come and take our order, punch it in on the kitchen computer, and then proceed to take care of us at the bar.

A man sat at the bar at 8:50 and sat right next to us. He was told he couldn’t order a hamburger, only pizza! Another lady came in at 9 and was told someone canceled her order, and she said it wasn’t her.

When we walked in, there was one gentlemen doing a pick up order and we were never spoken to or waited on by the bartender. Wish I could say I was the only one who experienced Tony’s lousy work ethic, but he continued with his rude remarks and treatment to other guests who came for pick-ups.

We never got an apology from Tony, but he apologized to other guests who didn’t have to experience his lack of customer service.

This is another person’s business and if you don’t like your job, you should move to doing something else. I would be appalled if I had my customers treated this way with a bar of dirty glasses that sat next to eating guests when the bar is EMPTY. I wish I could give so much credit to the young man who noticed we were being ignored…. He was embarrassed for us. The pizza and salad were outstanding though.

This is my favorite Mellow Mushroom. The food & service are both consistently great. Tonight, I brought my family who came in from out of town. They loved the experience & are considering bringing some back with them. It’s THAT good! Our server Madison was AWESOME! She took great care of us. I highly recommend this location.

Food was delicious and service was outstanding.
Our server Mac is so sweet and personable. She took care of us and made sure we were well taken care of the entire time.
We will surely be back again.

Our server Madison was fantastic. She was very quick and kept our drinks refilled. We would ask for her again. really good food and it was hot! The music was a little loud but we managed.

To preface, this is a restaurant we frequent and spend hundreds in throughout the year. We generally dine in. The staff is friendly and the food is fresh and hot. This past Sunday, we ordered a pizza for pickup. We arrived at the designated time and were presented the pizza for our inspection by opening the box lid. All looked fine and we left. Upon arriving home the pizza was cold, so we put it in the oven. After 15 minutes we plated the pizza for our dinner. The veggies were not cooked and when we got to the crust, it was raw in the center. Disgusted, I called the store to convey my experience. The woman who answered the phone responded by asking me if I had inspected the pizza prior to leaving. I said the pizza looked fine and a brief inspection would not have revealed the raw dough. She referred me to the manager who congratulated me on being proactive by reheating the pizza! He then suggested that I should have inspected the outer edges of the crust and requested pictures. When I suggested that he was unhelpful, he informed me that he was just investigating the situation. There was never an apology, never an offer to make things right. He was doubting the credibility of a frequent customer over a $20 pizza. Unbelievable!

I was not in the mood to cook after being stuck in this Atlanta traffic!! Mellow Mushroom is our go to spot for pizza and wings and they are literally a 2 minute drive from my home.

The food and service is always on point, our server was super nice and bubbly! We will be back

The building is huge and Beautiful! I really love the decor. The food is wack! I ordered the lunch special. Selected pizza and house salad. They put too much of whatever it was on the crust. My pizza wasn't hot. I had to ask the server to check on it, it seems like it had been sitting on the back. My salad was very basic. Mushroom soup was mediocre. Cobb salad was good but skimpy. It did not look like the picture at all. My coworker ordered a pizza and it was soggy. The manage looked dumbfounded about what to do. It's been a while since I've been and it will be even longer when I go back. They have plenty of free parking.

First time visiting this chain and I was really impressed. The BBQ chicken was on point. Really enjoyed the crust and the sauce was just right. The best part was the service though. I came in late, not long before closing and the lady that took my take out order was just really really nice. After a long day and a 2 hour drive in from B-ham, this wary business traveller appreciated it. Keep up the good work MM, I'll be back! 👍