Brooklyn Ice House

9/10/23 Placed an order for 1 dozen wings, potato skins and chicken quesadillas.

Was advised 40 minutes on phone.

Showed up at 45 minutes.

Order was not ready.

She insisted it was in the kitchen , though I watched her put the order into system.

She then blamed it due to the Browns game I've been there onweeknights when it was more crowded than today.

Being that it was freshly cooked, food shouldhave been hot. It was cool to lukewarm at best. I only live 7 minutes away from the bar.

I Love the Ice House. I don’t go as much as I did ten years ago but I always create warm memories and I’m always treated well, which is a real treat these days. It’s cash only, and I hope that by saying so in a review I’ll remember for myself next time. (There’s an ATM on site!)

Oh, and ten years ago I was here drinking my cash tips and I met my lawyer! It was one of the most New York City moments I’ve ever had.

Tasty burgers, cold beer, good customer service. What more could you want?

Ended up here for food on a Sunday night when everywhere else has closed their kitchens already. Classic cash only dive bar vibes, in a good way. ATM on site for cash!

This place is so awesome, that I proposed to my girlfriend there this past Saturday night. Our friend Liz brought us last year and we had such a great time and everyone was so nice and real, that it is now a special place for us. Such a great place with great people. Special thanks to Liz, Kerry, and Michael, as well as anyone there in the back with us when I popped the question. Awesome bar!

Such a dingy, no frills bar. Cheap beers, shots and food. Frito pie and hot dog was a nice snack. Fairly busy and pretty quick dor service. Would happy drop in again any time

Don't trick yourself looking from the outside. Once you get inside you will find a cozy, lay back and cool atmosphere to enjoy drinks, food or be in the backyard with friends. There is no push from the bartender to get drinks every time, no drunk people yelling, good spot with music, tv and special event. This has become our place and we had a great time everytime we show up. Don't expect to have a waiter checking on you all time time because the bartender is pretty much the one who run the tables when they can, still they are always available and helpful for whatever you need. Prices are very affordable including for drinks and they got special and happy hours.

Highly recommended place if you want a classic old school bar in a cozy warm place in a safe environment to eat or drink.

Mixed impressions. The bar itself is great, with decent selection of beers and liquors. Barmen were all friendly and efficient . Nice outdoor setting, but was impossible to get a waitress although there were not really many people to serve, it was half empty. So I went back to the bar.
The burger I ordered came out quite fast, but they forgot fries somehow - had to go myself to kitchen and remind them. And then I tried the burger - tasteless is a mild word to describe it. Better get McSomething than this. Really disappointing...