Famous Famiglia Pizzeria

Overall-It’s mid. On every level. Sometimes, that’s good enough.

And the AC is less than mid, it’s poor. Sweated my butt off in here trying to eat.

Pros:

< than $4 for a slice, which is rare these days.

More options, other than just pizza

Prices are moderate.

Cons:

Crust is isn’t thin- it’s borderline too thick. Good chew.

Ingredients are mid.

Overall:

Not a destination but if you get the itch and you’re walking by, it’s not a bad. I wouldn’t walk out of my way for anything in here though. Staff is really friendly- so there’s that.

I use to come here every weekend for a raisin bagel with cream cheese ! I asked for two strawberry jelly’s and he said 25 cents ! Thats not how u treat ur regulars ! He said they paid for it okay and you paid for the ketchup and salt aswell ! I’m
Never going back thank you ! The bagel is already overpriced I’m good

There’s a reason they’re “famous”, the pizza is too good! Perfect crust and rich in flavor, I’ve had my personal favorites buffalo chicken and pepperoni slices for a dine in lunch. It’s been such a treat for myself that I came back two days in a row. The place got a lot of history and you can tell by the numerous pictures of celebrities that came here over the years and behind the counter the guys are smiling and friendly. They also have a selection of hot dishes like meatballs, chicken Parmesan and even pasta. Definitely worth a visit if you’re looking for delicious pizza and great food in the Upper West Side.

Ok. I decided to order a pie again and it's been awhile. Because the last time they gave me a pie that was already made and here we go again it happened again. You see they'll take the already made pie and pretend your getting a well made fresh pie. So I received an already made pie and it was 24.00 and I paid the delivery guy 30.00 this is unbelievable I really think they think no one will know the difference. I guess it's my address location. But I'm pretty sure they will not have this behavior on cpw. I'm just saying. And I told the guy to make it fresh and hot... That's s is why I went the last time to pick it up and made the order right there. And I remember the guy saying you can call ahead and we'll have it ready for you. I said yeah I bet premade ready so fyi these are the practices familiar have in place. And mind you I'm 54 and a native New Yorker. So I know my pizza. I just had to share this and these cheating ways have to stop 🛑 the pizza is already dried out from Me opening the box only ,3 times... Not juicy atol never again ever not my money 💰

Best pizza & garlic knots in the city ! Better than dominoes or any other pizza place. I've been coming here since I was a little girl my grand parents would buy me a cheese slice pizza with broccoli. I love Famiglia Pizzeria.

Pizza by the slice ranging from $3-$5. Crust was moderate to thick, definitely not a thin crust. Lots of topping options, too.

The food was delicious 😊 We got the pepperoni and sausage (traditional) as well as chicken and broccoli (random). Everything was delicious and surprisingly high quality for the price point.

I grabbed a slice of pizza here to go while walking to my final destination. The pepperoni was good and the crust was not too dry. Their calzone is also good.

With its convenient location, I'd definitely stop here again if I am in the area. They do have more options than just pizza that I'll need to try next time.