Nicoletta Pizzeria

I won’t be back. They added 20% gratuity to my order for fast food pizza already made. When I said no thanks, the cashier was furious, dropping the F bomb. No thanks. I went to a restaurant next door and happily paid 20% for service. I will say the waterfront is wonderful, overwhelmingly people are friendly, and most restaurants are delicious. The view is stunning.

Just stop by to have cocktails. The bartender was very accommodating. Will be back very soon.

Horribleeeeee taste like they warmed old pizza up not worth the price at all

Great food, great prices, great atmosphere. Best pizza in the yard!

I ended not eating there due to the lack of customer service. They had a pepperoni pizza with jalapeños on it. My 11 year old asked for a plain pepperoni pizza. Without anyone in line the manager refused to add pepperoni to the cheese or cook a new one without jalapeños. He did offer to remove jalapeños from a precooked pizza. Doubt he’s ever tasted a pizza that has something removed and believes the taste is gone.

$40 for 2 small pizzas 2 cokes and 1 frozen lemonade. Way to expensive for what you get. The pizza tasted great and the view is awesome.

Staff are excellent & the location is tough to beat, but what matters is the pizza...

While their new pizza is better than their pizza of pre-2023, it's still just not that great compared to other options in the neighborhood. The crust is good, and the toppings are excellent but they're too spartan; without the toppings things taste a bit bland. But it feels like they're continuing to refine their recipes, so I'm hopeful things will only get better.

As of Spring 2023 the non-pizza menu is still unavailable, which is unfortunate since their hoagies used to be pretty good & pretty much the only such options in Navy Yard.

The pizza was pretty darn good! Especially with the view that came along with it. That’s a lot of bang for your buck!