Top Sandwich shops in Bridgehampton, United States

The staff were kind and lovely. The sandwich was the best and full. I almost regretted it if I didn't drink coffee. Both coffee and bread are excellent.

Wow!!! Great Pizza and Sandwiches!!! If you live in the area or just visting, make sure you pop in for the best Pizza on the East End. Friendly staff and quick service. Also one of the only places that serves fresh Gelato.

This is the BEST Pizza Place out here!!! Seriously, delicious food and great prices. This place is always packed and rightfully so. Definitely place your order for deliveries early because this place does not stop cranking out food for all of the Hamptons. Manhattan is too far away, but you still can get a NYC slice right here.🍕

This place is AMAZING AWESOME WONDERFUL AND DELICIOUS!!!! The staff INCLUDING delivery drivers are courteous and will call my elderly grammar if they don't have something and when they're on their way!

My recent visit to American Pie was fantastic! The ambiance was warm, the service attentive, and the pizza was an absolute delight. Crispy, flavorful crust with fresh toppings made for a memorable meal. Don't miss their buffalo chicken tenders- it's a must-try. I'm already looking forward to my next visit!

It is so delicious, I always end up ordering way to much, but it's still good even after re hearing it cold. I love the vodka sauce, pizza, and dipping their garlic knots in the broccoli and cheese soup (I was sick at time) was heavenly, filling and warm.

The food here is great, service is wonderful, and prices are reasonable. Girl at the counter was very nice and attentive. Would recommend to anyone in the area.

The staff is incapable of doing their job. We started ordering at the kiosk, but our gift card wasn’t working there so we had to go to the person cash desk. We ordered a salad and a sandwich, the gift card wasn’t working again (why do you have the option to put your card in your account when you really can’t use it online). We paid cash and after that we got 2 sandwiches, explaining that this is what we ordered, when in fact it was not. A little more customer oriented staff wouldn’t hurt. I love Panera bread, but this one doesn’t really exceed my expectations, or even close to them.

Staff is okay but manager should be changed. Food is $85 for a family of 3 my god.

The manager and his staff are amazing polite and incredibly efficient !! Thank you !

Found insect in food I recommend not going there anymore.

The food is decent, but, the pastries aren’t fresh. The riverhead location is better. I only recommend this location if you’re in the commons plaza and want a quick bite to eat.

So happy with the customer service the manager was very humbled. Not many people are this way. I had a good experience

They have done away with ham sandwich I eat. But I do like the pizza and chicken soup. Drink choices could be better.

This place is incredible and the staff is very delightful. I was stuffed after the Stromboli but the pizza was very delicious for my long drive home. If your ever in the Bridgehampton Area this is the place to stop. The prices are fair and you will not be disappointed. I will return for a few more slices.

Some of the best pizza on the East End. Crust is perfectly crispy but not too thin. Sauce is wonderful, not too sweet. Great service, too. Casual, simple environment with a TV on the wall usually showing sports.