Top Pizza restaurants in Brewster, United States

This was a true hidden gem. Wasn't expecting much but the pizza was phenomenal

Prices are outrageous taking advantage of the people in this town.
Unbelievable

Kenneth J Walsh

2 liter soda $5 Dollars
What?????

Real good pizza and food, nice old school pizzeria vibe and a good way. 👍

Food sucks
Went in there the other day it so hot,they had the door open ,it was 1000 degrees

My go to place for white pizza. There's just something about it that I can't say no...

Really nice! They let us bring our bikes in. Our slices were piping hot right out of the oven, and done quickly too. Huge slices.

COLD & RAIN COVERED FOOD DELIVERED TWO HOURS LATE!!!

I placed an order and told them where I lived they told me an hour.
Two hours later I called back to be told he would be leaving with my pizza when they’re closing.

This phone call was at 10:20PM.
I ordered at 8pm.

I live 15 minutes away from this pizzeria

They show up 2 hours and 45 minutes late.
Have the wrong phone number and hand me wet food & cold pizza.

Do not give them your business, if they were the only people open I’d rather starve.

The food was amazing!! So much to choose from and it was beautiful! And that's important but I will say the employees made this stop 100% better. They were super nice. Conversed with us about the neighborhood and the history of the place. Made us feel welcome. If we are ever near by again we will make the stop!! So worth it.

My family stopped at La Strada Pizza on our way to New England. We were looking for a slice of pizza. What we found was a wonderful, clean restaurant with amazing NY-style pizza. The staff was friendly, the food was excellent. There is even an Italian ice bar to enjoy for dessert. I can't say enough how impressed we were over this family-owned restaurant.

Amazing and authentic Italian food. The people are very friendly and they even have zeppolis! Fresh dough hand made to perfection. Whether stopping by fir a quick slice, dining in or take out, you won't be disappointed. A must go!

The name does have "pizza" in the title so I'm sure they're probably best at pizzas. We ordered a lasagna and chicken parm which were awesome but the sides were a let down. Stay away from the garlic bread with cheese and the cheese fries.

Great classic NY thin crust! Nice size slices with well balanced sauce, not too sweet not too salty. Loved the meat lovers slice and grandma's style!😋
Wish I tried this place sooner!

First time here, visiting from Seattle, I have never had such an amazing pizza, the crust is great, the topping are fresh and tasty. If you are around this area, do stop by, you won't regret it. The place is very chill 😎

Got to say hands down best pizza in the tri state area...ive had the privilege of meeting the owner vilson and was very impressed with the professionalism of him and his staff...and the food surly speaks for itself!!...he also owns scooters bar and grill and I have heard nothing but great things...they have a life long customer.
Sincerely,
TRAVIS GOODBOU

I went all over town and prices are ridiculous. I found Five Brothers and I was actually able to buy 2 slices for the price of 1. I’ll drive the extra miles, even with the price of gas the way it is.
Buy the large, they cut there large pies in 8 slices not 10. Enjoy!!

My family loves this spot! They are always accommodating, no cheese pizza? No problem. Wings with sauce on the side? Every time! The food is fresh when delivered and once we got everything but our pizza and the manager delivered it in about 20 minutes! Astounding service and always fresh, quality ingredients!

Very good pizza although I wish it could have had a little more cheese on it. Had one slice with sausage, onion and pepper, really good. Had another slice just plain, Iiked it. Clean place but the tablecloth on the table where I ate was slightly ripped. Good parking, too. Overall not the very best pizza I’ve ever had but not bad either.

Very disappointing! That pizza spot was very delicious and we had been ordering from them for 3 years. Until the pizza and buffalo wings delivered two days ago. I must say the wings tasted so old (called and told the guy about the wings he said they were delivered yesterday and if I wanted another one. Uh no because what if they all taste the same and it ruined my stomach) and the pizza was cold. Didn't seem fresh at all! Had a bad stomach & went to the bathroom. We will not order from them anymore.

Terribleeeee... ordered for food the be delivered contactless and these guys went to the extent to not even notify us when our food was delivered.

Sat outside for arleast 20 mins. So on top of having to cook my own food after delivery, the contents of our order was mediocre. Soggy bread on sandwichs deff not extra sausage as was ordered in our calzone... mozz stick were very spongey... and the sicilian pizza that was order was nothing butba cicago deep dish NOT Sicilian.

We will NEVER order here again and suggest no one else does either..

THESE PEOPLE ARE AMAZING! I called to get a delivery to my best friend who just got engaged. I asked if they could do a heart shape in pepperoni. Without hesitation they agreed- even though he said they have never done it before. It turned out GREAT! And she was so happy! THANK YOU!

Always fabulous, great food, owners & staff. Their single portions are close to family style.

One of the best NY style pizza I’ve had at a reasonable price too. The slices were large with a good cheese to sauce ratio. Sauce was a bit acidic, but not overwhelming. The dough was soft and held its form well, crust was crunchy on the outside and soft within. It wasn’t oily either. Their garlic knots were a bit small, but you get 6. They were really soft and not too garlicky. I’d get marinara sauce on the side.

As others have said, the previous owners were far better than the new guys. 5 brothers has ruined brewster square pizza. The pizza is less fresh, and they tend to screw up orders left and right. We gave them several chances because of their convenient location. They have grown skimpy on their serving sizes and the customer service is a joke. On the phone they are rude and poorly mannered. In the store, they are unorganized.

If I could give a negative star I absolutely would. We live about a few minutes away from this pizzeria so obviously we have done a lot of business with the old owners (who were fantastic) and also business with these new owners. We have given them several chances but tonight was the LAST straw. As a side note before I get into what happened tonight, this is what has happened in the past; wrong food, completely messed up food such as pasta not properly enclosed in its dish so its all over the bag, unprofessional attitude over the phone, 1 hour late deliveries when they say 20-30 minutes, the list goes on. So, tonight, we ordered from them giving them one last chance and my GOD are we DONE. We ordered tonight a pie now my family and I totally understand that its the day after Christmas we doubt that anybody would be cooking today, however don't say about 30 minutes maybe less when it took you over an hour to get here, okay? Next, our pies had NO toppings that we asked for on it but did we get charged for it? Of course we did. Now my stomach for some reason almost always hurts after eating their pizza for strange reason so I don't eat a lot of it but today I did not eat any of it due to the fact that it had some strange strange taste to it almost fishy-esque. My brother on the other hand did not encounter the joy of the fishy taste however he did find a nice piece of hair and a horrible stomach ache to match. Why didn't we call them to complain? We are TIRED of complaining! They NEVER do anything to compensate for the screw ups nor anything to make the situation better. It's so sad to know that the pizzeria that we have used since I was young has been left in a new name with horrible quality. You just lost customers.