Top Pizza restaurants in Piscataway, United States

Nothing special, a decent pizza with crust that this a bit dry. I tried the crust but made it out to bird food. Could stand some more sauce. The base was crispy with little to no flop. Would I buy it again? more than likely. Value is average for the area. Way better than some other pizza in town. Overall middle of the road.

They have the best chicken Cesar salad. I havent had their pizza yet but if your looking for a good salad this is definitely the place.

My first time here I tried the eggplant parm pizza and I would like to say it was phenomenal. I never thought the two can be mixed some perfectly lol. Im definitely coming back!!!!

I was very hungry and I got a pizza for breakfast. And the pizza was amazing. And a nice big slice. Love big slices of pizza.

Just had couple slice of pizza and couple knots. Food was very good but customer service was EXCELLENT! very nice and humble welcome by Matt, he kinda forgot to get the knot out of oven on time which wasn’t bad at all if anything I would say it was perfect for me but just because he realized the perfection wasn’t according to how they serve it he didn’t charge me for it. These days where ppl don’t care about what they provide for what they charge, this was an absolute example of honest customer service out here Piscataway. Happy and proud to business with Piscataway Pizza!

We had 2 pizza slices. The pizza crust is ok, crisp on the bottom. The sauce and pepperoni didn't have any flavor, and the sauce was sparse.

Their crispy fries are great. (5/5)
Their cheesesteak is good but usually half of it is just bread and missing meat. (4/5)
Their pizza is below average at best. (3/5)

The pizza crust is very thick and cardboardy.
Cheese and sauce are tasteless.
Ratios of sauce, doe and cheese are off.

An accidental snack but this pizza was one of my best. I wasn’t expecting to have such a soft crust but this one was melt in the mouth! The guy was really great and in a cheerful mood. He took great interest in helping us with vegetarian options and even confirmed if we were vegan or vegetarian. Appreciate the detail! There were 3 veggie options and we ended up getting 3 slices of 2 of those. One with mushroom and another with mozarella. The tables are spacious and you would enjoy a slice or two on a lazy day sitting there. If you eat meat, they have a lot of other options too. Combos with buffalo wings are also available. We also got garlic knots which were equally melt in the mouth. All in all, a good place. I would definitely go again.

Ordered Garlic Knots, Margherita, Mushroom! Pizzas were good! Crunchy Crust with flavorful sauce, fresh Mozzarella and Basil. Mushroom was good too. Didn’t really like the garlic knots. Felt like it is made from garlic oil and not butter. Could taste oil more than garlic. But 5 stars for great service and extremely friendly staff. Good place for a pizza slice overall. I would surely recommend their Pizzas.

Their chicken francese is soooo delicious!!!
the best one I have ever had! The chicken was seasoned 👌🏼
The delivery took a whiiile but it was so worth the wait!!!

Completely dissatisfied with this order. I ordered a Sicilian slice of pizza, tiramisu, and lasagna. They sent me a hard old slice of cheese pizza which was disgusting. The tiramisu slice was OLD AND HARD, tasted like it’s been sitting in the fridge for days, not to mention how small the slice was and I paid 5 something for it. And the lasagna was swimming in oil. First and LAST time I will be ordering from this place. Paid almost 30 dollars for this order. This place doesn’t even deserve one star. I will be waiting for my refund from Uber Eats. Please see the pictures to see for yourself.

Excellent pizza. Locals told me about it. Best pizza in Piscataway. Love a slice, Xtra meatballs

I asked for alfredo and recieved marinara sauce
And the sauce is all over the bottom of the box
Wished I would of never gave a $10.00 tip..
And how am I supposed to eat my food with out Utensils???
Don't think I'll be ordering again..
I'm sure my accountant will appreciate the Marinara sauce receipt...

This place has the best Italian cheeseburger, they make their own patties, and meatball parm sub in the area. The service isnt the greatest. They also keep changing what comes in their sandwiches every time you visit but once you clear that up, it's delicious. I wouldn't go there for the pizza though. It's just something about the lack of cheese they put on their pies and the lack of salt in the dough. I would recommend it for the subs.

Stelton Pizza in a strip mall along a fairly busy road. There is plenty of parking and, once inside, plenty of seating. I don't recall there being many options behind the glass at the counter as far as getting slices to-go was concerned, but there was enough to make a selection. The staff was friendly and Halloween decorations were impressive and helped add to the atmosphere.

The plain slice was flavorful with a good amount of sauce and a good amount of toasting of the cheese. The crust and base were crispy, though the crust did have a bit of excess flour that can be seen in my picture. The pasta slice was pretty good. I appreciated having the cheese over the pasta and I found that it helped contain the slice better than some others. I would definitely eat here again given the opportunity.

The slices here are big but they sacrifice quality for size. I honestly dont know why I keep giving this place a chance to step it up. Their pizza is flavorless and if you try to touch it up with Garlic or oregano, it's like it rejects it.