Mi Casita Shelbyville

Mi Casita was once our favorite restaurant in Shelbyville. Unfortunately our last visit was very uncomfortable. Our server was very rude. I saw him roll his eyes at us multiple times. I'm a server myself so I have compassion for other servers. But he seemed very annoyed with us. We were a very easy 5 top. My kids were very well behaved so the server didn't need a reason to roll his eyes at us. We will not be returning to this restaurant.

I always rate my favorite Mexican restaurants by how good the salsa is. While they don't have my absolute favorite salsa, this is hands down the best in Shelbyville.
The service is always great regardless of who is waiting on us and the food is delicious. They've recently made improvements to their menu so be sure to check out the new items.

I had the lunch buffet. It is the best Mexican buffet I’ve had. Several good options but the best, by far, was the garlic parmesan wings!
It’s recommended by the locals and definitely worth a try!

Love this Mexican lunch buffet in Shelbyville. Each dish tastes different which is a nice change to a lot of Mexican restaurants. Big fan of the chicken dishes and carnitas

The best Mexican food! We’ve tried many different items and they are all good. The raspberry margarita (on the rocks) is the best we’ve ever had. Ask for Heriberto as your server, you won’t be disappointed!

The waiter was not very friendly. He acted like we were bothering him. They brought us chips and salsa. There was a black hair in our chips. We paid for our soda's and our queso Blanco that was $15.00 and left. Won't be back.

I've been 3 times. Food is Amazing! Love taco Tuesday's.
My first server was fantastic, no complaints. Do to her and the food is the reason we came back. The 2nd one, the guy didnt do a good job at all. Never refilled our drinks. The owner ended up coming and refilled them, they wasn't even busy. Waiter was not good at all. 3rd time. They was busy, waitress was training. I asked for no lemon with my tea. Because im allergic. She brought it back with lemon on the cup. 🤦‍♀️ i waited forever for my sour cream. Waitress didnt ask us how the food was, or if we needed refills. When finished we stacked and put our plates at the end of the table, to let the waitresses know we was finished. She never came to give us our bill. So we waited a while befor we went to cash ourselves out. The owners wife ranged us up. And charged us for 2 teas and a lemonade. Mind u it was only 2 of us and we never got refills. So why did we pay for 3 drinks🤷‍♀️