Goose Hollow Inn

I had the Turkey Reuben. It was scrumptious, full of flavor, well composed! I can see why a foodie had recommended this place.
The establishment carries a wise old character, evidently developed and refined over many years of service.
I definitely want to eat here again!

I cannot believe what I experienced during my recent visit to this place. I had frequented it a few times in the past for drinks, but this time my friends and I decided to treat ourselves to a meal to celebrate the end of the week. It was a Thursday evening, and after work, we were eager to unwind and enjoy some food. I opted for a beet and quinoa salad with shrimp and feta, while my friend ordered a shrimp cocktail. Little did we know, that decision would lead to a horrifying dining experience.

When our meals arrived, we were utterly appalled by the state of the shrimp. Instead of the normal sized shrimp (like 2 or 4 of them) that we expected, they served us these tiny, slimy canned shrimp that looked and smelled raw and rancid. It was revolting! I paid $15 for my salad with a $4.97 upcharge for the shrimp, and my friend spent $8 on his dish. But what we got was far from worth it.

I tried my best to salvage my meal by picking around the shrimp, but I couldn't bring myself to finish it for fear of getting sick. My friend couldn't even bear the smell of his dish, let alone eat it. It was a nightmare. How could they serve something so utterly repulsive?

I feel like they should have at least warned us that they don't use real shrimp. It's false advertising at its worst. The staff didn't bother to check on us or ask us how how meal was. I can't blame them entirely, but it's still unacceptable.

I've never felt compelled to leave a negative review before, but this experience left me no choice. I was beyond disappointed, and needless to say, we won't be returning anytime soon.

Drinks were good and affordable, so that's a plus I guess.

DING DONG we have a 5 Star Champion! - This was a fantastic find. We ate three different sandwiches and they were all outstanding. Service was very friendly and the atmosphere was cosy and welcoming. Definitely the best Sandwich on this trip

The vibe of this spot is wonderful. 🌬🌲☂️
Walked in on an early cold & cloudy Saturday afternoon.
The woody rock 🎸 classic tavern vibes had me feeling at home. Had no problem knocking clean a whole turkey reuben and coke.
Could sit and digest before heading out, even when it got busy. Noticed almost everyone else had ordered reubens too. 🥪

*Worked at a restaurant in Florida for some years and folks loved our reubens, but they don't come close to these. ✅

It has been over a year since my last visit to the Goose Hollow Inn, and it's as good as it was before. I worked in the neighborhood for 30+ years, and this place served me many lunches and beers (after work).

It's good when the food tastes like you remember it too. I went with a Goose Hollow staple, a Ruben sandwich, and a side of their delicious ranch dressing to dip my carrots in. And you can't forget the house made potato salad which is very good too. I think I've had everything on the menu, and it's all good.

There are a few parking spots on site and a few visitor parking spots on the street where permits are required for the Goose Hollow neighborhood. Their deck is covered with heaters, which provides more seating.

Great job, Clark family!! I miss working next door to you.

Definitely get the Ruben

Classic ruben ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
- it was perfectly horse radishy
- liked the cheese
- melted and toasted well

Tuna melt ⭐⭐⭐✨
- not better than the Ruben

They claim to be the best Reuben and they do a pretty good job delivering. I'm not a huge fan of Reubens but I figured I better try it and it was pretty good. Potato salad that came with it was decent. Decent selection of drinks. Made for a really good lunch visit with friends out on the patio. I could tell there were a lot of regulars.