Bagel Supreme

Our bagels were very fresh, our 2 lunch sandwiches were excellent! Service was great and they were friendly. Can't wait to go back when I visit Paramus again.

I recently got back to Paramus for a short trip to see family, & was recommended this Deli. I went three days in a row if that tells you anything!! Plethora of options, fresh and delicious bagel and lunch sandwiches, and the iced coffee/ muffins have been a total staple for my mornings back home!

The people working the counter, the bagel and coffee, you guys are great. Really enjoy coming here for the great service. Very good quality.

Had a small, simple order and it took a really long time. Hardly any cheese was given, but price was higher than many other bagel shops. Will not return.

Place has gone downhill with the new staff specifically. Been coming here for years. Food is good if they get the order right, and that's a big IF. Messing up the orders the past 3 times going to them. Staff don't pay attention to the order. Last order asked for put the receipt for an order of 8 ppl. Dont find the receipt at work. I go back to ask the staff blamed me that I didn't wait. And they still managed to mess up an order in there. Supported their business for years, no more.

Was excited to try this place, sadly was disappointing. When I went almost everyone behind the counter seemed pretty young, I thought that was great to see young teens/ adults working so that's a plus. Now to food , bagel with scallion cream cheese, one look , I could tell this was a loss. The cream cheese was so oily and runny it was like melted butter. To be fair I tasted it with my finger, never again. Now on to the sandwich which had the strongest onion odor. I took it out of bag and damm. The onions were expired for sure. Again to be fair I picked out onions and tried sandwich, I couldn't stomach it the taste was very off. So now both my orders were trashed, wasted money. Sorry it's a no for me.

Love everything about Bagel Supreme! The owner and all of the workers have a great attitude and are all super friendly and dedicated. Yes, the prices went up (just as they did EVERY WHERE), but the high quality of all of their foods never went down. Great breakfast wraps, bagels, and sandwiches. Their fridge is always fully stocked with juices, water, Gatorade etc. And there is always fresh coffee. They also have homemade muffins that are delicious!

There's a million bagel spots in NJ but tried this one on a whim and we will definitely be trying to go back! Bagels are delicious and they don't put excessive cream cheese like most places do. I also ordered an egg sandwich which was one of the best I've had (although they ran out of round rolls so I settled for a hero).

They also have gluten-free cookies if you have to avoid wheat.

Parking can be tricky at busy times but there is additional parking around the back of the building.