Bagel Pub

My bagel was cold, which was disappointing. Toasting would have helped, but they didn’t offer and I didn’t think of it. I’m visiting from CA and I was looking forward to a good New York bagel, but this wasn’t it. It’s a cute vintage place. Crummy music.

I’ve been coming to Bagel Pub at this location for +12 years. They have the best bagels in my opinion in Park Slope. Over Bagel World, La Bagel, Terrace Bagels, Bagel Hole, etc. They also have the largest ones. Some other ones are maybe 70% or 60% the size. While I have seen the price go up over the years. A bagel used to cost $1 flat including tax but now a single loose bagel 🥯 costs over $2. But cost aside, they have the largest and best bagels in the slope. Good place to catch up with a friend for coffee. My go-to bagel is the whole wheat sesame.

I appreciate a stuffed bagel, solid customer service, and a calming environment to enjoy my food in.

Bagel pub has it all, from an indoor dining section to an outdoor seating with sections basking in the sun, and in the shadows. Have your pick with where you would like to sit.

Enjoy the bites of goodness. You can’t go wrong with lox and avocado.

One of my favorite bagels place in the neighborhood. I been coming here for years and since the renovations the place looks really nice (cleaner) they did a really good job, also they have a backyard and all the staff is friendly. There’s many choices of cream cheese’s and bake goods, also the wraps are really good. Coffee is a little strong but I like it that way. My favorite thing to order is the Lox #1 with pumpernickel bagel is always on point (order that you won’t regret it), love it!

Chain bagel stores with several convenient locations in Brooklyn. The colourful display window definitely excites all bagel lovers!

The shop always invents new special spread flavors which never bores you. If you are a sweet tooth, you could order mixed berries or oreo fillings served with blueberry or raisin bagels. Low fat spread available with tons of variations, like tofu and veggie ones.

＊Egg everything bagel w/ tofu veggie cc
＊ Onion bagel w/ bacon chipotle cc

Bagels:
The bagel would be perfect if the texture was more chewy and denser. Giant size which could hardly be grabbed by one hand! Girls with smaller appetite (like me) would be satisfied after eating just half of it.

Onion bagel has a prettier round bagel shape and smells alluring after toasted. While egg everything bagel is less desirable (looks more like a sandwich). The roasted garlic on top unfortunately doesn’t enhance the overall taste.

Cream Cheese:
Generous layer of tofu veggie cream cheese yet it was a bit too greasy for me. Instead, the amount of bacon chipotle cream cheese was adequate to reach a perfect balance. A bit spicy but acceptable for me.

My Recommendations:
Onion bagel, bacon chipotle cream cheese

Worth Returning ? Maybe

Dropped in to grab bagels and a few sandwiches to start the day. Staff was courteous and food was ready in minutes. Good bagels and an impressive collection of crème cheese flavors that make it look more like a gelatoria than bagel shop. All around a good experience and everyone’s order (all 8) where on point. Well played Bagel Pub, well played 😀

Bagel Pub makes the best bagels in the hood, IMO. The are just the right size. Not so large that the center is a bit raw. Not so small that you feel you are not getting your money’s worth. Get The Hulk, best green smoothie with pineapple, greens, mango, and coconut water. Yum. Vegan spreads, too. I give he Blueberry Bagel 💯 out of 💯. Eat it plain and if you go there early enough, it’s hot! Nice staff. Always moving and filling orders.