Local Guides World
Bustling counter-service joint featuring inventive bagels, coffee & salads, plus an open kitchen.
264 W 40th St, New York, NY 10018

Photos

There are no photos for this place yet!

Reviews — 8

J W
at 2024 May 04
J W
at 2024 May 04
Bagel Mart Midtown: A Classic Choice, Now With Gluten-Free Goodness!
Bagel Mart in Midtown is a reliable spot for a classic New York bagel experience. They offer a wide variety of fresh bagels, schmears, and breakfast sandwiches, all at reasonable prices.

Here's the exciting news: Bagel Mart recently added gluten-free bagels to their menu! This is a huge win for those with dietary restrictions who crave a delicious bagel fix.

The Regular Bagels:

The standard bagels at Bagel Mart are fantastic. They come in all the New York favorites like plain, sesame, poppyseed, everything, and onion. They're boiled for that chewy texture and baked to a perfect golden brown.

The Gluten-Free Game Changer:

Now, onto the real star of the show - the gluten-free bagels! They come in a few flavor options, and while they might not be exactly like their gluten-filled counterparts, they hold their own admirably. They have a nice density and a good amount of chew, making them a satisfying breakfast option.

Overall:

Bagel Mart hits the spot for a classic New York bagel experience. The addition of gluten-free bagels makes it even more appealing, allowing everyone to enjoy a delicious start to their day.

Recommendation: Try a classic everything bagel with your favorite schmear, or give the gluten-free option a go if you have dietary restrictions. You won't be disappointed!
Geyner Crisanto
at 2024 Apr 28
Geyner Crisanto
at 2024 Apr 28
For a Sunday morning breakfast, The Bagel Market is the place to be. A small wait 5-10 minutes on a nice atmosphere and after you place your order the wait is worth it on every bite and a good Late. Very recommended.
Grace Berg
at 2024 Apr 25
Grace Berg
at 2024 Apr 25
Convenient location near times square. Went for breakfast and they had great bagels, friendly service, was fairly busy but still able to get a table, they have a handful downstairs and upstairs.
Chris Soloniewicz
at 2024 Mar 23
Chris Soloniewicz
at 2024 Mar 23
Delicious breakfast bagels!
Went just after opening so was a little quiet still, got served very quickly and it didn't take long to get our food. The bagels were amazing super soft and tasty 😋 3 bagels and drinks for around $30
Martin Roberts
at 2024 Mar 21
Martin Roberts
at 2024 Mar 21
Bagels are the go to breakfast when a Brit visiting New York City and this was my second visit to a 'Bagel Market' during this trip. This store had a good vibe and seating upstairs and downstairs. The selection of fillings was wide and the toasted Everything Bagel with Lox Scallion Cream Cheese that I had was very tasty... Although I think I do prefer the Bacon Scallion Cream Cheese (which I had from another Bagel Market). The Americano coffee I had was good too. Had a Hash Brown which was okay but a bit soggy and greasy, a bit crispier would have been better.
George Messinia
at 2024 Feb 24
George Messinia
at 2024 Feb 24
Located on 40th Avenue, it consists of a large ground floor with tables in the background and a mezzanine with tables.
We have there the most delicious bagels in New York and we visited almost every day!
Fast and helpful service.
It has a wide variety of savory, sweet bagels, as well as vegetarian options.
Teresa B
at 2024 Jan 15
Teresa B
at 2024 Jan 15
great service - quick and friendly! really great bagel and vegan cream cheese (but they had a million possible toppings and combos, all looked great!)
would definitely recommend for a quick breakfast/coffee break/lunch, but it’s probably not a place i would hang out for a long time or eat at a super leisurely pace, the stone bench along the back wall is fine for a while but probably not conducive to lounging.

Nearby Places

Similar Places

Related Places